Breaking Britain: Scotland’s choice

Image

Above: Scotland’s Future launch. Photo: Scottish Government

Fifty years ago, the idea that Scotland would leave the United Kingdom would have been almost impossible to imagine. But this week the Scottish Government launched a white paper, Scotland’s Future, setting out the case for just that in next year’s independence referendum.

For a party proclaiming the case for divorce, the SNP seem curiously keen on many aspects of the United Kingdom. The Queen would still be head of state. The pound sterling would still be Scotland’s currency. And the white paper even reassures Scots that they’d still enjoy Doctor Who, Strictly Come Dancing and CBeebies – even though the BBC would be replaced by a Scots equivalent. Heaven help us if Waybuloo is the only thing holding back the break up of Britain.

As many have said, it’s far from certain if the remaining UK countries would allow all this to happen. But it’s a clever ploy by Alex Salmond to suggest Scotland can have it all outside the union.

Scotland is, of course, right to decide its future. The fact the vote is even happening is an indictment of the failures of successive Westminster governments to govern for the whole of these islands. As I wrote a year ago, there are echoes here of the way British malevolence and incompetence led Ireland to independence rather than home rule.

I still hope that Scotland chooses to help us reshape Britain, rather than break it. Scotland has played a hugely important part in our nation’s history. It, like Wales, has shown that we can enjoy multiple identities: Scottish/Welsh and British. That diversity is a great model for life in these islands. It would be a great shame to diminish Celtic influence in Britain.

Goodbye Virgin Media, hello BT Infinity

Today marked the end of relationship that has lasted almost 16 years.

One January day in 1998, I got online with Virgin Net. I liked the quirky, informal brand. The service was just as likeable. We’ve shared five houses over the years, but the last year or so hasn’t been so good. Virgin’s ADSL service has been painfully slow. I’ve resented paying £20 a month for it. So when BT launched Infinity, I decided that our days with Virgin were over. Today was the day we said goodbye to Virgin, and hello to BT.

It’s been a very easy switch. The man from BT Openreach arrived just before 9am, and by 9.20am we were up and running with BT Infinity.

The best speeds I’ve achieved recently with Virgin? 3.55 Mbps (download) and 0.85 (upload). The best today with BT was 39.6 (download) and 10.45 (upload). The chap who installed it told me to expect fluctuations in speed at first, but this is a really good start.

I was sorry to say goodbye to Virgin, despite the really poor recent service. When things hit rock bottom a few years ago, they admitted they had underestimated demand and were adding capacity – which they did. They’ve been very responsive on social media. But in the past six months I got fed up with paying a premium price for a poor service.

The big lesson is not to have your email address with your internet service provider. This makes switching much more hassle. At least with your own domain name or Gmail you can move without changing email address.

PS: I did have a two year separation from Virgin 10 years ago. When broadband came along, Virgin was slow to offer it. So I went with BT. In June 2004, I complained about Virgin Net’s lack of broadband in a letter in the Guardian’s Technology section. To my amazement, I got an email from Sir Richard Branson early on the morning of publication apologising and offering a return Virgin Atlantic Upper Class ticket. We took up the offer and switched back to Virgin as soon as they offered broadband. No wonder I’m sad to leave now after all these years…

PPS: I should add that I had an ADSL, rather than a cable, service from Virgin. I know from my parents that Virgin’s cable service is excellent.

iMovie 10: another Apple disaster

At first glance, Apple’s latest iMovie 10 looks like a brilliant move. Not least because it’s free.

But, as seems to be the way these days. Apple has lost its attention to detail and quality control.

Today, I got what seemed like a nice surprise. iMovie 10 can edit video shot on GoPro’s hugely popular Hero 3. Until now, you needed to convert files to a format that iMovie could edit.

I shot a test film today. Most of the video from my bike ride uploaded to my Mac. I added the missing files later. But iMovie couldn’t cope with the fact I hadn’t uploaded them all at once. Although it successfully copied the edited film to iMovie’s Theatre mode (sorry – Theater – no concession to non Americans here…) it proved impossible to share the final video. It would only recognise the other files on the camera, not the Mac.

So amazingly annoying.

This is a classic illustration of iMovie’s failure:

Screen Shot 2013-11-17 at 22.16.16

 

iMovie gives no clue how to stop it ‘referencing media on the camera’. (I presume this means it hasn’t downloaded the video files from the camera. Yet I have done just that three times. Useless.)