Poundbury: Prince Charles’ model Dorset village, 30 years on

Poundbury

As you approach Dorchester from the west, you see a dramatic sight: a fire station that looks like a design from the era of George III. The royal connection is real: this is Poundbury, the model village created by Prince Charles to bring to life his dream of building new communities using traditional architectural styles.

Charles famously campaigned against modern architecture in the 1980s, describing a proposed extension to the National Gallery in Trafalgar Square as “a monstrous carbuncle on the face of a much-loved and elegant friend”. He made those comments in a 1984 speech to the Royal Institute of British Architects – and incidentally compared the design to that of a municipal fire station. We now know what Charles would like a fire station to look like. The speech killed the proposed design.

Charles later said that he didn’t intend to drag Britain back to the 18th century, or to begin a style war. “All I asked was for room to be given to traditional approaches to architecture and urbanism.”

He had the chance to practise what he preached in Dorchester. The Dorset planning authorities saw Poundbury as a perfect location for new houses for the county. The Duchy of Cornwall, which he controls, owned the land and was able to commit to a decades-long master plan drawn up by Luxembourg architect Léon Krier featuring traditional designs.

Brownsword Hall, Pummery Square, Poundbury

We first visited Poundbury in 2009. We enjoyed lunch at the Engine Room cafe, which was a relaxing place to take a toddler. When we returned this week (with that toddler now 12 years old) the Engine Room was as good as we remembered it, despite the complications posed by the COVID-19 pandemic. (The staff are lovely.) And Poundbury’s early buildings are now looking more natural with 25 years of weathering taking away the new-build look.

Weathering nicely

Above: images of Poundbury

I really like Poundbury. Most of the architecture is pleasing and the layout of the village is attractive, with curved streets and vistas. There are plenty of community spaces – such as Pummery Square, pictured earlier in this post – and over a third of the homes are affordable housing, a higher proportion than most new estates. This isn’t just a dormitory development: there are shops, cafes, a pub and workshops, and over 2,000 people work in the village. Until recently, Dorset Cereals had its factory in Poundbury, before moving to Poole.

Hidden parking – behind this building. Photo: Poundbury factsheet, 2019

I also like the subtle way in which the designers have made Poundbury a welcoming place for pedestrians and cyclists. There are no road markings, which naturally makes drivers cautious. The road layout encourages exploring on foot or two wheels. And the hidden car parking – for example, behind Woodman Court opposite the Engine Room – avoids pavement parking which is such a menace for wheelchairs and pushchairs in many towns.

This is also a place to reflect. Wandering through Poundbury on August bank holiday Sunday I spotted this quiet garden, sponsored by the churches of Dorchester. It reminded me in a way of Postman’s Park in the City of London – a place to pause and contemplate. Opposite is an attractive playground that we discovered in 2010. I confess that Owen and I had a go on the seesaw, despite our combined age of 68…

Poundbury’s monumental phase: Strathmore House, Queen Mother Square

Since our last visit, the area north of the Engine Room has been developed as Queen Mother Square, named after Prince Charles’s grandmother, Queen Elizabeth the Queen Mother. This is where my appreciation of Poundbury falters. The architecture is pretentious and out of keeping in a small town. It’s the fire station blunder again. I presume that Prince Charles felt the Queen Mother’s memory needed a pastiche of Buckingham Palace. (And only something that grand could command prices of £800,000 for a two bedroom flat.) It’s a shame as the rest of the village feels right.

The Queen Mother surveys the Royal Pavilion

The most pretentious building is Strathmore House, on the east of the square. It’s the work of Quinlan Terry, who designed Richmond Riverside in London. (I work in one of those riverside buildings.) Terry’s work has been criticised as a pastiche, so it was ironic that he was asked to design for Poundbury, which has been unfairly criticised as a fake. A glance at historic Dorchester’s town centre would have shown that this kind of architecture was misplaced in Dorset’s county town. And I hate the lazy English habit of naming places after the royal family: apparently Charles insisted that the pub in Queen Mother’s Square should be named after his wife’s title, the Duchess of Cornwall. How depressingly predictable and feudal.

But these are quibbles. I still think Poundbury represents a noble attempt to create an attractive place to live and work that is in keeping with Britain’s rural traditions. I would happily live there if I were based in Dorset. And it is still growing. We could see the signs of further expansion to the north of Queen Mother Square, with a magnificent view north towards Charminster

As we returned to Prince Charles’s model village this week, I remembered a project I was involved with when work began at Poundbury. Back in 1990, Eagle Star Insurance unveiled plans for Micheldever Station Market Town. The intention was remarkably similar to Poundbury: to recreate a traditional market town to provide desperately needed new homes. Eagle Star produced a memorable advert to explain why a new town was preferable to expanding countless villages: a lovely spot rather than an ugly rash.

Micheldever Station was, and is, a small community around a railway station, as the name suggests. It’s no beauty spot. Bill Bromwich, the quietly spoken project manager for Eagle Star, was an immensely likeable colleague who won respect through the campaign, including this interview in The Independent. But the campaigners won the day – unlike in Poundbury, where the power of the planning authorities and royal authority won the day.

Dorchester remains one of my favourite English county towns. It has the timeless appeal of Thomas Hardy’s Casterbridge, as I blogged this week, and Poundbury has added to its charms rather than diminishing them. That is a tribute to Prince Charles, Léon Krier and the forward-thinking planners of Dorset 30 years ago.

2 thoughts on “Poundbury: Prince Charles’ model Dorset village, 30 years on

  1. This is an enjoyable blog Rob, thank you. It’s been a while since I visited Poundbury but share your views of it as you might expect. I have a boxfull of material relating to Micheldever Station Market Town from when I was PR manager at Eagle Star Properties which was bravely promoting the Market Town and it looks as fresh today as it did then. Looking back, with Bill Bromwich and Iain McInnes we did some extraordinarily good PR but we were up against powerful opposition, not least the then Leader of Hampshire County Council, Dudley Keep, who lived nearby and was vehemently oppoed to the concept. He had strong support from influencers such as a couple of peers and industry leaders who lived nearby. It was he who famously, on a TV debate, said that ‘Hampshire’s doors are firmly closed. If you want to move to Hampshire, then go to France instead’. He was the ultimate BANANA (Build Absolutely Nothing Anywhere Near Anybody).

    Although the design reflected Hampshire market town pastiche, Micheldever Station Market Town was, in the 1980s, nevertheless well ahead of its time: with a large cofhort of affordable housing; combined heat and power fuelled by low carbon fuel (similar to Danish systems); grey as well as fresh water supplies to all properties; water recycling; solar energy, wildlife corridors, properties that would have been wheelchair-friendly throughout … it ticked all the righrt boxes. The site was on low-grade agricultural land that was not easy to farm. To my mind it is a tragedy that ultimately the opposition won through while Eagle Star was acquired by Zurich and the impetus faded. So what do we have instead of well-designed discrete communities? Just look at the sprawl that nearby Basingstoke has become. I look back with some pride at what we achieved and the wide public support that we garnered along the way. At public meetings Micheldever Station Market Town was often cited as a model of good communication and public dialogue. And more than ever, there is a place today for new communities of this sort.

    • Glad you liked it Ian, and thanks for your excellent comments. I thought of you as I added the reference to Micheldever Station Market Town.

      I had forgotten Dudley Keep’s comment ‘go to France’. That was indeed the era of BANANA and NIMBY (Not In My Back Yard). Today’s acute housing crisis is the tragic legacy of all that, with many 30 year olds still living with their parents because they cannot find affordable homes.

      The opposition was indeed too strong. If anything, today’s knee-jerk social media culture makes it even easier to oppose, and harder to make a reasoned case for change. Eagle Star conducted a model PR programme over many years, and you can be proud of your leading role in that. It wasn’t to be, but I was pleased that Poundbury shows what might have been.

      I have always tried to avoid opposing change for the sake of it. I’m very conscious that I have lived in various new homes over the years, and use roads and railways that once cut through open land. I am one of the few people in our village not opposed to HS2, which will pass underneath it. Our son’s outdoor activity centre is closing because of HS2 next month, and various access roads are being built. You may be interested in my recent blogpost on this.

      Best wishes

      Rob

What do you think? Please leave a comment!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s