The West Lothian question is back in the news.
It was famously asked by Tam Dalyell, MP for West Lothian, during the Seventies devolution debates.
He asked why he should have the right to decide on matters affecting England when his English counterparts had no couldn’t influence on these issues in Scotland.
Devolution didn’t survive the 1979 general election, so the West Lothian question was buried for a generation. But it’s back in town after Labour delivered devolution in 1999.
The answer is simple: turn the United Kingdom into a true federal state. Germany manages the relationship between the federal state and its regional governments very well. Come to that, so do the former British dominions in Canada and Australia – despite the occasional tensions in Quebec.
Today’s grumbles from the English about the dominance of the Scots in British life are nothing new. In the late 1970s, the English complained about the Taffia. The Callaghan government had a clear Welsh influence, with the PM and his deputy (Michael Foot) representing Welsh constituencies, and the home secretary and lord chancellor both hailing from west of Offa’s Dyke. Along with the president of the European Commission, Roy Jenkins….

