This referee’s decision is NOT final

In sport, the referee’s decision is final. Anyone challenging the man in black risks a caution or an early bath.

In politics, life isn’t that simple. The Government simply move the goalposts, as the victims of collapsed pension funds discovered this week.

The Parliamentary Ombudsman, Ann Abraham, ruled that the Government was guilty of maladministration. Department of Work and Pensions leaflets had misled members of company pensions schemes, leading them to think their pensions were safer than they proved. As a result, Abraham said the Government should compensate 85,000 people who lost their pensions when their companies had gone bust.

The ruling was a huge boost to workers at companies such as Allied Steel & Wire in Cardiff. Over 1,300 people lost their jobs and pensions when the company went under. But Tony Blair rejected the Ombudsman’s ruling. He said the Government should not have to compensate people when private pension schemes fail.

It’s pure hypocrisy. Government ministers are quick to tell private companies what they can and cannot do. They’re instant experts on subjects they’ve never studied. Here’s a quick lesson for Tony. Take a look at the Financial Ombudsman Service. It’s the money industry’s referee. Banks, building societies and insurers agree to accept the ref’s decision, even when privately they think the man in black needs his eyes tested (to borrow an old sporting saying). When are you going to accept the ref’s decision?

We feel desperately sorry for workers who find their pensions snatched from them just before they retire. It’s time to put our hands in our pockets and help them out. It may cost the country a billion or two. But how much has Iraq cost us?

Rebel run

Tony Blair is facing another rebellion. His education reforms are at risk. Labour’s traditional supporters are up in arms, and many MPs are still prepared to give the Prime Minister a bloody nose.

As John Major discovered after 1992, losing a landslide majority makes Government more challenging. Rebels have more influence. As Match of the Day’s John Motson would say, the big decisions are all six-pointers.

But Blair has only himself to blame. He threw away his huge majority a year early. Yet none of the political commentators has noticed that the PM’s recent Commons traumas could have been avoided by allowing the 2001 parliament to run its course. They’re all insiders. You can’t expect them to notice the obvious!

Accrington Stanley: back from the dead?

For years, Accrington Stanley was a byword for football failure.

The club was ejected from the Football League in 1962. No other team suffered the same fate until Workington in 1978. The club that replaced Workington was Wigan Athletic, which reached the heady heights of the Premiership this season. And flourished.

Don’t cry for Accrington Stanley. They’re poised to return from the dead and re-enter the Football League. It’s taken a long time – John Profumo was still a Government minister and Winston Churchill an MP when they lost their league status. But if Wigan are anything to go by, they could be challenging for a place in Europe in 2033…

Remembering Dunblane

Does 13 March 1996 mean anything?

It’s unlikely, unless it was the day you got married, picked up your winning lottery cheque or landed your dream job.

Or had children in the village school in Dunblane, Scotland.

It was the day the name Dunblane became famous for all the wrong reasons, like Lockerbie and Hungerford in the 1980s. When the simple act of going to school proved deadly for 16 young children and their teacher, Gwen Mayor.

Hungerford had shown that small-town Britain was not immune to American-style massacres. But Dunblane was even more painful because it involved young children.

We’ll be hearing some of the stories of those whose lives were devastated by Thomas Hamilton 10 years ago this week. The BBC’s website yesterday interviewed Dr Mick North, whose daughter Sophie lost her life that day. (http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/4795260.stm). And the Guardian’s family section today tells the story of Pam and Kenny Ross, who lost their daughter Joanna. (http://www.guardian.co.uk/family/story/0,,1728042,00.html)

For them, 13 March 1996 will live forever.

Profumo: far from a scandal

He gave his name to the most notorious British political scandal of the twentieth century. He slept with a prostitute and resigned as war minister after lying to Parliament. Yet John Profumo, who died today, will be remembered as a good and honourable man.

For over 40 years after his downfall, Profumo devoted his life to helping the poor in London’s East End through the Toynbee Hall charity. In his darkest hour in 1963, he turned up at the charity, offering to help with the washing up. He continued to help and inspire the charity’s fundraising efforts throughout the following four decades. Toynbee Hall today posted a heartfelt tribute to its president – see www.toynbeehall.org.uk/news.htm.

Tomorrow’s headlines will inevitably focus on 1963. But 1940 should also figure prominently. Profumo was one of the rebel Tory MPs who forced Neville Chamberlain to resign after the Norway debacle, leading to Churchill’s premiership. It was a brave act by the 25 year old MP, who had only just been elected. History might have been very different had Profumo and his fellow rebels not put country before party.

Don’t follow the Highway Code!

Can you judge risk? Do you know when your actions put you in danger’s way?

‘Of course!’, you reply. You know better than to jump out in front of a car. You’re hardly likely to leave a chip-pan on the hob while you nip to the loo. And you’re the last person to leave the kids on their own while you go to the pub for a swift pint.

So why is our modern society so hopeless at assessing risk? Why do we create greater risks by trying to minimise inconsequential ones?

This is why the proposed changes to the Highway Code must be opposed.  The new wording will tell  cyclists to “use cycle cycle facilities … where they are provided” (Rule 58).  If confirmed, this would open the way for driver’s insurance companies to seek to reduce the damages for any cyclists injured by their clients, on the basis that the cyclist’s failure to use a nearby cycle facility (in accordance with the Highway Code) represented "contributory negligence".

This rule change will further marginalise cycling. One of our local roads, the A404 from Amersham to Little Chalfont, has a cyclepath on the pavement. Cyclists using the path have to give way to every side road. By contrast, cyclists on the main road have a clear passage. If the new Highway Code ruling comes into effect, cyclists who make the very sensible decision to use the main road could be be held partially responsible if a driver hits them, even if the driver is totally at fault. 

This is a blatant breach of natural justice. Far worse, it favours obese coach potatoes at the expense of those who try to keep healthy. (In much the same way that the move towards compulsory cycle helmets is likely to cost thousands of lives.) Small wonder that the next generation is likely to reverse the trend to greater life expectancy.

Our local MP. Cheryl Gillan, has reported that she has written to the transport minister to pass on our protests. Let’s hope that common sense prevails.

See the CTC website for more information. www.ctc.org.uk/DesktopDefault.aspx?TabID=4303

Arsenal: the Real thing

Who needs goals? Last night’s 0-0 draw between Arsenal and Real Madrid at Highbury was pure theatre. A reminder of the ability of sport to keep you at the edge of your seat.

This win brought life back to Arsenal’s season. It gave credence to Arsene Wenger’s claim that the Gunners are building a new team of Invincibles to take to their new super-stadium at Ashburton Grove. And best of all, it showed Arsenal’s gravitas and dignity against the bluster of Jose Mourinho, whose oneupmanship is fast losing him the respect he earned in his first season in English football. The Special One is becoming the Embarrassing One.

Real Madrid are a fading force. But this was a great result for Arsenal. An unforgettable drama in Highbury’s last season. Time for an encore!

Dydd Google Dewi!

(A variation on Dydd Gwyl Dewi, or St David’s Day, for the uninitiated!)

Google today celebrated our national day by introducing Wales’s national symbol, the daffodil, into its logo.

Well done, Google!

Happy St David’s Day to Wales’s Senedd!

Wales has its Senedd. The new National Assembly building was officially opened today, a landmark on Cardiff Bay. It’s a world-class building – something to be proud of.

The critics, predictably, are saying that the money should have been spent on hospitals and schools. They’re wrong, for two overwhelming reasons.

First, Wales is now largely self-governing. That’s good for democracy. Why should the nation be governed from London or Brussels? Good government means everyone should be able to watch ministers and Assembly members in action. The Assembly’s first jerry-built, second hand home failed utterly to allow this to happen. The new building is a model of a modern parliament building. It’s open to the people. It’s a meeting place for everyone,rather than a select few. It’s not intimidating. In short, it’s very Welsh.

Second, this is a landmark building. It will stun visitors to Cardiff, in the same way that the city’s 100 year old civic centre does. Yet a century ago critics railed against Cathays Park. Now, we marvel at the vision of our Edwardian forefathers. The critics would never have built City Hall, the Houses of Parliament or Sydney Opera House. They were proved utterly wrong. Today those iconic creations help define their cities. Wales’s new Senedd will do the same for Cardiff.

Political apathy – who cares?

Willie Whitelaw famously accused Labour of stirring up apathy.

Apathy about politics – and the slump in voting at elections – is back in the news. The Power Commission this week published a report analysing the problem. It looks at a host of ideas including voting at 16, electoral reform and internet democracy. (What price elections on eBay?)

It’s odd how these studies of voter apathy never tackle the real problem: the politician’s promise. Cheaply given, cheaply broken. No wonder the voters switch off. So it’s time to introduce Ofpol: the politicos’ regulator. In the same way that Ofsted polices our schools and Ofwat our water companies, Ofpol would hold politicians to their promises. We’d have league tables revealing which ministers had kept their word – and which had broken them the moment they’d said hello to their chauffeur.

But it’s never going to happen. Because it would have to be agreed by politicians. And they’re never going to give up the right to fib to the voters!