It’s so frustrating when you hit a brick wall dealing with a company. I’ve been a customer of Marks & Spencer Bank for over 30 years, starting with the old chargecard, then taking out a credit card. (I also ran PR for M&S Bank, then called M&S Money, for three years from 2005.) I’m a big fan of the M&S Club Rewards scheme. Yet all this counts for nothing given how hard it is to contact the company, and get problems solved.
About a month ago, my M&S credit card stopped working on Apple Pay. It seemed to have been removed from my Apple digital wallet. I tried adding it back in, but got this message:

This simply wasn’t true. There was no sign of my M&S card in my wallet on any of my Apple devices.
I tried again, this time on my Apple Watch (the only device I regularly use to pay with Apple Pay). A different brick wall this time:

Yet at the same time, I was receiving almost daily emails from M&S Bank saying my card had been added to Apple Pay:

It was time to call M&S Bank. After all, Paul Stokes told me to call, adding that they’d be delighted to help me, day or night. This was clearly a company that cared about its customers..
When I called, it was very clear that Paul Stokes was telling a complete porkie by saying M&S would be delighted to help. I endured about three minutes of being treated as a naughty schoolboy for having the temerity to call the company. The very first words I heard – in an automated message, naturally proclaimed:
‘Our phone service is for customers who cannot use our digital services.’
There followed repeated nagging to download the app, use the chat, register for the app… And, needless to say, after three minutes I heard the ubiquitous warning of high call volumes. Who knew: customers want to talk to their bank – especially after it sent them an email inviting them to call. (At least M&S didn’t claim ‘your call is important to us’.)
I eventually got to speak to a couple of staff, who told me that M&S Bank knew it had a problem with Apple Pay. They made some changes behind the scenes, and told me to try again in a few hours. I did, but got all the same error messages. Despite this, I still received yet another email from Paul Stokes the next morning, saying my card had been successfully activated. Which it hadn’t. And telling me to call, even though M&S Bank really doesn’t want customers to call. And can’t help. And even if I called, it wouldn’t solve the problem.
Why we need to speak to a human
One day, Artificial Intelligence (AI) might become good enough for customers to say, ‘Get M&S Bank to solve problem activating my credit card to work with Apple Pay’, and the bot will magically solve the problem or put the customer through to someone who can. Until that day, people will still need to talk to other people. Companies like M&S think their own time is more important than that of their customers. No wonder we all get so frustrated.
UPDATE, Tuesday 6 October
I’m pleased to report that I was contacted by a member of M&S Bank’s executive complaints team after I published this post. She called me to apologise for the problem, and explained that M&S Bank had raised an enquiry with MasterCard to try to resolve it. She added that M&S Bank didn’t know whether the problem lay with M&S, MasterCard or Apple Pay. She promised to update me when she had any news.
That’s excellent customer service.

Leave a Reply